Individual 9-hole scores
| Score | Name | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 33 | Jonathon Stapleton | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/17/2005 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 34 | Andrew Wismer | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/18/2004 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 35 | Jonathon Stapleton | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/18/2004 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 37 | Mike Ward | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/17/2005 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 37 | Christian Rowe | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/17/2005 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 37 | Joe Kiss | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/17/2005 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 37 | Nicholas Hoffman | Shootout at Stonehedge | 4/13/2018 | Stonehedge North |
Team 9-hole scores
| Score | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|
| 146 | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/18/2004 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 151 | Pat Flowers Invitational (John Carroll) | 4/17/2005 | Fowler's Mill Golf Course |
| 166 | Shootout at Stonehedge | 4/14/2018 | Stonehedge South |
Individual 18-hole scores
| Score | Name | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 67 | Tim Smith | 9/29/1984 | MIAA Jamboree #4 | Pine River Country Club |
| 68 | Jason Hartman | 9/21/1994 | MIAA Jamboree #3 | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 68 | Mark Raven | 4/14/1999 | Tri-State Invitational | Zollner Golf Course |
| 68 | Rick Gibbons | 10/5/2002 | MIAA Jamboree #5 | Hills of Lenawee Golf Club |
| 68 | Mike Ward | 9/3/2004 | Comet Classic | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 68 | Joe Kiss | 9/16/2006 | MIAA Jamboree #3 | Pine River Country Club |
| 68 | Brock Gleadall | 9/23/2006 | MIAA Jamboree #5 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 68 | Joe Kiss | 9/23/2006 | MIAA Jamboree #5 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 69 | Ed Novak | 1937 | MIAA Tournament | Kalamazoo Country Club |
| 69 | Jason Hartman | 9/17/1994 | MIAA Jamboree #2 | Pine River Country Club |
| 69 | Mike Dinner | 5/12/2004 | NCAA DIII Championships | PGA of Southern California |
| 69 | Mike Dinner | 9/4/2004 | Comet Classic | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 69 | Joe Kiss | 10/1/004 | Aquinas Invitational | L.E. Kaufman Golf Course |
| 69 | Derrick Sayers | 9/17/2005 | MIAA Jamboree #3 | Pine River Country Club |
| 69 | Steve Ross | 10/1/2005 | MIAA Jamboree #3 | Hills of Lenawee Golf Club |
| 69 | Eric Ross | 4/6/2008 | Denison Invitational | Granville Golf Course |
| 69 | Brock Gleadall | 8/30/2008 | Lou Collins Classic | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 69 | Justin Ardelean | 9/9/2010 | MIAA Jamboree #1 | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 69 | Nick Julian | 4/14/2013 | Strimer Invitational (Ohio Wesleyan) | Glenross Golf Course |
| 69 | Nicholas Hoffman | 3/21/2021 | Mount St. Joseph Spring Invitational | Indian Ridge Golf Course |
Team 18-hole scores
| Score | Date | Tournament | Course |
|---|---|---|---|
| 285 | 9/23/2006 | MIAA Jamboree #5 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 289 | 9/18/2004 | MIAA Jamboree #3 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 289 | 9/9/2010 | MIAA Jamboree #1 | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 290 | 9/18/2002 | MIAA Jamboree #2 | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 290 | 9/1/2007 | Lou Collins Classic | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 291 | 9/9/2002 | Jon Spiess Memorial Tournament | Ironwood Golf Course (Ohio) |
| 291 | 10/5/2002 | MIAA Jamboree #5 | Hills of Lenawee Golf Club |
| 291 | 10/4/2004 | Aquinas Invitational | L.E. Kaufman Golf Course |
| 291 | 9/20/2008 | MIAA Jamboree #4 | Hills of Lenawee Golf Club |
| 291 | 9/29/2008 | MIAA Jamboree #6 | Wuskowhan Players Club |
| 291 | 4/15/2009 | Trine Invitational | Zollner Golf Course |
| 292 | 4/14/1999 | Tri-State Invitational | Zollner Golf Course |
| 293 | 8/30/2008 | Lou Collins Classic | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 293 | 9/6/2008 | MIAA Jamboree #1 | Pine River Country Club |
| 293 | 9/27/2008 | MIAA Jamboree #5 | Zollner Golf Course |
| 294 | 9/14/2004 | MIAA Jamboree #2 | Bedford Valley Country Club |
| 294 | 4/17/2007 | Defiance College Open | Kettering Golf Course |
The 9-hole scores above are since the 2003-04 season, and the 18-hole scores on this webpage are since the 1978 season. If you have documented proof of a lower score, please submit it to Geoff Henson, Assistant Athletic Director for Sports Information and Communications.