| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet35 | Start of 1st quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | Brad Taylor kickoff 53 yards to the ALMA12, Tyler Watters return 17 yards to the ALMA29 (Jesse Woods-Cur;Jimmie Melton). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma29 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Tyler Watters for 28 yards to the OLIVET43, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Ryan Sersaw). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet43 | Jarrett Leister rush for 8 yards to the OLIVET35 (Cody Ross;Eric Fox). |
| Alma | 2-2 | at Olivet35 | Jon Bricker rush for loss of 5 yards to the OLIVET40 (Eric Fox). |
| Alma | 3-7 | at Olivet40 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Dakotah Dockter (Andrew Pabst). |
| Alma | 4-7 | at Olivet40 | Alex Crocker punt 40 yards to the OLIVET0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 31 yards, TOP 01:54 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 13:06. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | OLIVET ball on OLIVET20. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | Javier Lara rush for 10 yards to the OLIVET30, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet30 | Javier Lara rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET34 (Charlie Kempf). |
| Olivet | 2-6 | at Olivet34 | Braden Black pass complete to Anthony Skurato for 23 yards to the ALMA43, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Sam Young). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma43 | Braden Black pass complete to Javon Moore for 6 yards to the ALMA37 (Sam Young;A. Mcclelland). |
| Olivet | 2-4 | at Alma37 | Braden Black pass complete to Anthony Skurato for 7 yards to the ALMA30, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Sam Young;Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma30 | Javier Lara rush for 5 yards to the ALMA25 (Terry Calagon;Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 2-5 | at Alma25 | Javier Lara rush for 3 yards to the ALMA22 (Justin Thelen;Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 3-2 | at Alma22 | Braden Black pass complete to Kyle Bryson for 7 yards to the ALMA15, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma15 | Braden Black rush for 5 yards to the ALMA10 (A. Mcclelland;Eric Strickler). |
| Olivet | 2-5 | at Alma10 | Braden Black sacked for loss of 3 yards to the ALMA13 (Charlie Kempf). |
| Olivet | 3-8 | at Alma13 | Braden Black pass complete to Anthony Skurato for 12 yards to the ALMA1 (Adam Nelson), PENALTY OLIVET ineligible downfield on pass (Anthony Skurato) 5 yards to the ALMA18, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 3-13 | at Alma18 | 2nd and 12. |
| Olivet | 2-12 | at Alma18 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Javier Lara. |
| Olivet | 3-12 | at Alma18 | Braden Black sacked for loss of 4 yards to the ALMA22 (Terry Calagon), PENALTY OLIVET holding declined. |
| Olivet | 4-16 | at Alma22 | Anthony Edwards field goal attempt from 39 BLOCKED, recovered by ALMA Adam Nelson at ALMA17 spot at ALMA17, clock 05:47 (blocked by Adam Nelson), Adam Nelson for 1 yard to the ALMA18. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 58 yards, TOP 08:50 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma18 | Jon Bricker rush for 1 yard to the ALMA19 (Anthony Skurato). |
| Alma | 2-9 | at Alma19 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Dakotah Dockter for 17 yards to the ALMA36, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Curtis French). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma36 | PENALTY ALMA false start 5 yards to the ALMA31. |
| Alma | 1-15 | at Alma31 | Jon Bricker rush for no gain to the ALMA31 (Justin Madar). |
| Alma | 2-15 | at Alma31 | Jarrett Leister pass intercepted by Beau Langs at the ALMA37, Beau Langs return 2 yards to the ALMA35 (Erik Hines). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 13 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma35 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 04:16. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma35 | Alante Sims rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALMA37 (Terry Calagon;Gavin Smith). |
| Olivet | 2-12 | at Alma37 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Jason Barbosa. |
| Olivet | 3-12 | at Alma37 | Braden Black rush for 11 yards to the ALMA26 (Eric Strickler;D. Gogolowski). |
| Olivet | 4-1 | at Alma26 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Dominik Givens. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:21 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma26 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 01:55. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma26 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Tyler Watters for 5 yards to the ALMA31 (Beau Langs). |
| Alma | 2-5 | at Alma31 | Jarrett Leister rush for 6 yards to the ALMA37, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Eric Fox;Zachary Gropp). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma37 | Jon Bricker rush for 1 yard to the ALMA38 (Dylan Hunt). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 12 yards, TOP 10:09 |
| | | Olivet College 0, Alma College 0 |
| Alma | 2-9 | at Alma38 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Alma | 2-9 | at Alma38 | Jarrett Leister rush for 5 yards to the ALMA43 (Justin Madar), PENALTY OLIVET offside declined. |
| Alma | 3-4 | at Alma43 | Jon Bricker rush for 6 yards to the ALMA49, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Trevor Garbow). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma49 | Jarrett Leister rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET46 (Curtis French;Remi Johnson). |
| Alma | 2-5 | at Olivet46 | Jon Bricker rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET43 (Noah Keefer;Ryan Armstrong). |
| Alma | 3-2 | at Olivet43 | Jon Bricker rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET41, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Noah Keefer;Ryan Armstrong). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet41 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Tyler Watters. |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Olivet41 | Jarrett Leister rush for no gain to the OLIVET41 (Ryan Armstrong). |
| Alma | 3-10 | at Olivet41 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Erik Hines for 26 yards to the OLIVET15, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Curtis French). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet15 | Adam Nelson rush for no gain to the OLIVET15 (Curtis French), PENALTY ALMA illegal block (Zachary Roth) 10 yards to the OLIVET25, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 1-20 | at Olivet25 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Erik Hines (Nate Roberts). |
| Alma | 2-20 | at Olivet25 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Ricky Roth for 8 yards to the OLIVET17 (Logan Seal). |
| Alma | 3-12 | at Olivet17 | Jarrett Leister sacked for loss of 5 yards to the OLIVET22 (Quaye Cobbs), PENALTY OLIVET face mask (Quaye Cobbs) 10 yards to the OLIVET7, 1ST DOWN ALMA, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet07 | Jon Bricker rush for no gain to the OLIVET7 (Curtis French). |
| Alma | 2-G | at Olivet07 | Jarrett Leister rush for loss of 10 yards to the OLIVET17 (Justin Madar). |
| Alma | 3-G | at Olivet17 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Jon Bricker for 7 yards to the OLIVET10 (Beau Langs). |
| Alma | 4-G | at Olivet10 | Jack Pryde field goal attempt from 27 GOOD, clock 06:46. |
| | | Alma College 3, Olivet College 0 |
| | | Drive: 17 plays, 64 yards, TOP 10:09 |
| | | Brandon Alridge kickoff 62 yards to the OLIVET3, Tyre Alexander return 20 yards to the OLIVET23 (Rhyan Smith). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet23 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 06:53. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet23 | Javier Lara rush for loss of 1 yard to the OLIVET22 (Terrence Tyson;Frank Furnari). |
| Olivet | 2-11 | at Olivet22 | Braden Black sacked for loss of 2 yards to the OLIVET20 (Terrence Tyson). |
| Olivet | 3-13 | at Olivet20 | Braden Black sacked for loss of 3 yards to the OLIVET17 (Cory Herrmann). |
| Olivet | 4-16 | at Olivet17 | Anthony Edwards punt 36 yards to the ALMA47, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma47 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 04:43. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma47 | Jon Bricker rush for 3 yards to the 50 yardline (Nate Roberts). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Alma50 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Dakotah Dockter (Curtis French). |
| Alma | 3-7 | at Alma50 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Tyler Watters for 50 yards to the OLIVET0, 1ST DOWN ALMA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:48. |
| | | Jack Pryde kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 10, Olivet College 0 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 53 yards, TOP 00:55 |
| | | Brandon Alridge kickoff 61 yards to the OLIVET4, Curtis French return 24 yards to the OLIVET28 (Troy Gahm;Terry Calagon). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 03:41. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | Braden Black rush for loss of 1 yard to the OLIVET27 (Sam Young). |
| Olivet | 2-11 | at Olivet27 | Braden Black rush for 14 yards to the OLIVET41, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Brandon Wegenke). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet41 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Kyle Bryson (Terry Calagon). |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet41 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Tyre Alexander, dropped pass. |
| Olivet | 3-10 | at Olivet41 | Braden Black rush for no gain to the OLIVET41 (Eric Strickler). |
| Olivet | 4-10 | at Olivet41 | PENALTY ALMA holding (Brandon Wegenke) 10 yards to the ALMA49, 1ST DOWN OLIVET. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma49 | Braden Black pass complete to Dominik Givens for 5 yards to the ALMA44, out-of-bounds (Sam Young). |
| Olivet | 2-5 | at Alma44 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Jason Barbosa. |
| Olivet | 3-5 | at Alma44 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Dominik Givens. |
| Olivet | 4-5 | at Alma44 | Anthony Edwards punt 33 yards to the ALMA11, fair catch by Jon Bricker. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 28 yards, TOP 01:41 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma11 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 02:00. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma11 | Grant Wilson rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALMA9 (Noah Keefer;Justin Madar). |
| Alma | 2-12 | at Alma09 | Timeout Alma College, clock 01:47. |
| Alma | 2-12 | at Alma09 | Robert Gibson rush for 9 yards to the ALMA18 (Trevor Garbow). |
| Alma | 3-3 | at Alma18 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 01:37. |
| Alma | 3-3 | at Alma18 | Robert Gibson rush for 2 yards to the ALMA20 (Ryan Sersaw). |
| Alma | 4-1 | at Alma20 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 01:27. |
| Alma | 4-1 | at Alma20 | Alex Crocker punt 31 yards to the OLIVET49, Jason Barbosa return 1 yards to the 50 yardline (Jon Bricker). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:39 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet50 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 01:21. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet50 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Kyle Bryson (Terry Calagon). |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet50 | Braden Black pass complete to Jason Barbosa for 14 yards to the ALMA36, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (J. Chittenden). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma36 | Braden Black pass complete to Dominik Givens for 5 yards to the ALMA31, PENALTY OLIVET illegal motion 5 yards to the ALMA41, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 1-15 | at Alma41 | Braden Black pass intercepted by Eric Strickler at the ALMA24, Eric Strickler return 0 yards to the ALMA24. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:29 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma24 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 00:52. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma24 | Team rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALMA22. |
| Alma | 2-12 | at Alma22 | Team rush for loss of 2 yards to the ALMA20. |
| Alma | 3-14 | at Alma20 | End of half, end of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| | | Alma College 10, Olivet College 0 |
| Alma | 3-14 | at Alma20 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, ALMA ball on ALMA35. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 00:52 |
| | | Brandon Alridge kickoff 64 yards to the OLIVET1, Javon Moore return 22 yards to the OLIVET23 (Troy Gahm;Eric Strickler). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet23 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 14:54. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet23 | Braden Black pass complete to Tyre Alexander for 39 yards to the ALMA38, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Eric Strickler;F. Constant). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma38 | Braden Black pass complete to Tyre Alexander for 4 yards to the ALMA34 (Sam Young;Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 2-6 | at Alma34 | Alante Sims rush for 13 yards to the ALMA21, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (F. Constant). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma21 | Garrett Reid rush for 1 yard to the ALMA20 (Adam Nelson;Rhyan Smith). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Alma20 | Braden Black rush for 15 yards to the ALMA5, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 1-G | at Alma05 | Alante Sims rush for 2 yards to the ALMA3 (Frank Furnari;Charlie Kempf). |
| Olivet | 2-G | at Alma03 | Jimmie Melton rush for 2 yards to the ALMA1 (Frank Furnari;Charlie Kempf). |
| Olivet | 3-G | at Alma01 | Braden Black rush for 1 yard to the ALMA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:43. |
| | | Anthony Edwards kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 10, Olivet College 7 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 77 yards, TOP 04:11 |
| | | Brad Taylor kickoff 55 yards to the ALMA10, Tyler Watters return 7 yards to the ALMA17 (Demetrius Brown), PENALTY ALMA illegal block 9 yards to the ALMA8, 1st and 10, ALMA ball on ALMA8. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma08 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 10:13. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma08 | Jon Bricker rush for 6 yards to the ALMA14 (Curtis French). |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Alma14 | Jarrett Leister sacked for no gain to the ALMA14 (Justin Madar). |
| Alma | 3-4 | at Alma14 | Jarrett Leister sacked for loss of 8 yards to the ALMA6 (Noah Keefer). |
| Alma | 4-12 | at Alma06 | Alex Crocker punt 46 yards to the OLIVET48, Jason Barbosa return -3 yards to the OLIVET45 (Tyler Watters). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 02:01 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet45 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 08:12. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet45 | Javier Lara rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET49 (Austin Smith;Charlie Kempf). |
| Olivet | 2-6 | at Olivet49 | Javier Lara rush for 15 yards to the ALMA36 (Adam Nelson), PENALTY OLIVET holding 5 yards to the OLIVET44, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 2-11 | at Olivet44 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Kyle Bryson, PENALTY OLIVET ineligible downfield on pass 5 yards to the OLIVET39, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 2-16 | at Olivet39 | Braden Black pass complete to Garrett Reid for 8 yards to the OLIVET47 (Adam Nelson;Sam Young). |
| Olivet | 3-8 | at Olivet47 | Braden Black sacked for loss of 4 yards to the OLIVET43 (Austin Smith), fumble by Braden Black recovered by OLIVET TEAM at OLIVET43. |
| Olivet | 4-12 | at Olivet43 | Anthony Edwards punt 45 yards to the ALMA12, downed, PENALTY OLIVET illegal shift 9 yards to the OLIVET34, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 4-21 | at Olivet34 | Anthony Edwards punt 30 yards to the ALMA36, fair catch by Jon Bricker, PENALTY ALMA illegal block 9 yards to the ALMA27, 1st and 10, ALMA ball on ALMA27. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 11 yards, TOP 03:17 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma27 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 04:55. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma27 | Jarrett Leister rush for 1 yard to the ALMA28 (Dan Wright). |
| Alma | 2-9 | at Alma28 | Grant Wilson rush for 8 yards to the ALMA36 (Noah Keefer). |
| Alma | 3-1 | at Alma36 | Grant Wilson rush for 2 yards to the ALMA38, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Drew Miller;Justin Madar). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma38 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Dakotah Dockter for 20 yards to the OLIVET42, 1ST DOWN ALMA. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet42 | Jarrett Leister rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET37, out-of-bounds (Noah Keefer). |
| Alma | 2-5 | at Olivet37 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Erik Hines, QB hurry by Justin Madar. |
| Alma | 3-5 | at Olivet37 | Jon Bricker rush for loss of 1 yard to the OLIVET38 (Curtis French). |
| Alma | 4-6 | at Olivet38 | Alex Crocker punt 18 yards to the OLIVET20, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 35 yards, TOP 03:53 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 01:02. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | Braden Black rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET25 (Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 2-5 | at Olivet25 | Braden Black pass complete to Javier Lara for 7 yards to the OLIVET32, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Eric Strickler;Gavin Smith). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 12 yards, TOP 04:49 |
| | | Alma College 10, Olivet College 7 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet32 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet32 | Braden Black rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET39 (Frank Furnari). |
| Olivet | 2-3 | at Olivet39 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Jason Barbosa (Austin Smith). |
| Olivet | 3-3 | at Olivet39 | PENALTY OLIVET false start 5 yards to the OLIVET34. |
| Olivet | 3-8 | at Olivet34 | Braden Black pass complete to Anthony Skurato for 10 yards to the OLIVET44, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (A. Mcclelland;Adam Nelson). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet44 | Javon Moore rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET45 (Gavin Smith;Terry Calagon). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Olivet45 | Javier Lara rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET49 (Gavin Smith). |
| Olivet | 3-5 | at Olivet49 | Javier Lara rush for 2 yards to the ALMA49 (Charlie Kempf;Gavin Smith). |
| Olivet | 4-3 | at Alma49 | Anthony Edwards punt 37 yards to the ALMA12, fair catch by Jon Bricker. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 31 yards, TOP 04:49 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma12 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 11:13, ALMA ball on ALMA12. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma12 | Grant Wilson rush for 3 yards to the ALMA15 (Noah Keefer). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Alma15 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Tyler Watters for 11 yards to the ALMA26, 1ST DOWN ALMA, out-of-bounds (Beau Langs). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma26 | Grant Wilson rush for 4 yards to the ALMA30 (Curtis French). |
| Alma | 2-6 | at Alma30 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Dakotah Dockter for 8 yards to the ALMA38, 1ST DOWN ALMA, QB hurry by Justin Madar. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma38 | Grant Wilson rush for no gain to the ALMA38 (Andrew Pabst). |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Alma38 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Ricky Roth for 8 yards to the ALMA46 (Curtis French;Nate Roberts). |
| Alma | 3-2 | at Alma46 | Grant Wilson rush for 3 yards to the ALMA49, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Remi Johnson;Logan Seal). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma49 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Erik Hines. |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Alma49 | QB hurry by Quaye Cobbs. |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Alma49 | Grant Wilson rush for 6 yards to the OLIVET45 (Noah Keefer;Nate Roberts). |
| Alma | 3-4 | at Olivet45 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Erik Hines. |
| Alma | 4-4 | at Olivet45 | Alex Crocker punt 35 yards to the OLIVET10, fair catch by Jason Barbosa, PENALTY OLIVET roughing the kicker (Justin Madar) 4 yards to the OLIVET41, 1ST DOWN ALMA, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet41 | Grant Wilson rush for 6 yards to the OLIVET35 (Nate Roberts). |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Olivet35 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Tyler Watters. |
| Alma | 3-4 | at Olivet35 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Erik Hines for 2 yards to the OLIVET33 (Logan Seal). |
| Alma | 4-2 | at Olivet33 | Timeout Alma College, clock 04:18. |
| Alma | 4-2 | at Olivet33 | PENALTY ALMA false start (Allen Wardwell) 5 yards to the OLIVET38. |
| Alma | 4-7 | at Olivet38 | Alex Crocker punt -3 yards to the OLIVET41, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 50 yards, TOP 07:06 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet41 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 04:07, OLIVET ball on OLIVET41. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet41 | Braden Black rush for 11 yards to the ALMA48, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma48 | Braden Black pass complete to Tyre Alexander for 2 yards to the ALMA46 (Bryan Wonski). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | at Alma46 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Kyle Bryson. |
| Olivet | 3-8 | at Alma46 | Braden Black rush for 3 yards to the ALMA43, out-of-bounds (Frank Furnari;Gavin Smith). |
| Olivet | 4-5 | at Alma43 | PENALTY ALMA personal foul (Gavin Smith) 15 yards to the ALMA28, 1ST DOWN OLIVET. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma28 | Javier Lara rush for 3 yards to the ALMA25 (Terry Calagon;Gavin Smith). |
| Olivet | 2-7 | at Alma25 | PENALTY OLIVET false start (Jacob Cramer) 5 yards to the ALMA30. |
| Olivet | 2-12 | at Alma30 | Braden Black rush for 19 yards to the ALMA11, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Gavin Smith). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma11 | Braden Black pass incomplete to Kyle Bryson. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Alma11 | Javier Lara rush for loss of 1 yard to the ALMA12 (Frank Furnari). |
| Olivet | 3-11 | at Alma12 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 00:55. |
| Olivet | 3-11 | at Alma12 | Braden Black rush for 12 yards to the ALMA0, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:47. |
| | | Anthony Edwards kick attempt failed. |
| | | Olivet College 13, Alma College 10 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 59 yards, TOP 03:20 |
| | | Brad Taylor kickoff 35 yards to the ALMA30, Troy Gahm return 20 yards to the 50 yardline (Thomas Gary-Hom). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma50 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 00:43, ALMA ball on 50 yardline. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma50 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Tyler Watters, dropped pass. |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Alma50 | Grant Wilson rush for 12 yards to the OLIVET38, 1ST DOWN ALMA, out-of-bounds. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet38 | Jarrett Leister rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET33, out-of-bounds (Nate Roberts). |
| Alma | 2-5 | at Olivet33 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Erik Hines, QB hurry by Justin Madar. |
| Alma | 3-5 | at Olivet33 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Tyler Watters for 3 yards to the OLIVET30 (Trevor Garbow). |
| Alma | 4-2 | at Olivet30 | Timeout Alma College, clock 00:06. |
| Alma | 4-2 | at Olivet30 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 00:06. |
| Alma | 4-2 | at Olivet30 | Jack Pryde field goal attempt from 47 GOOD, clock 00:00. |
| | | Olivet College 13, Alma College 13 |
| Alma | 1-G | at Alma35 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 20 yards, TOP 00:43 |
| | | Olivet College 13, Alma College 13 |
| | | Olivet College 20, Alma College 13 |
| Alma | 1-G | at Alma35 | Start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Alma35 | Change of possession, OLIVET ball on ALMA25, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 20 yards, TOP 00:43 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma25 | Javier Lara rush for 1 yard to the ALMA24 (Frank Furnari). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Alma24 | Braden Black pass complete to Jason Barbosa for 7 yards to the ALMA17, out-of-bounds (Brandon Wegenke). |
| Olivet | 3-2 | at Alma17 | Javier Lara rush for 17 yards to the ALMA0, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | Anthony Edwards kick attempt good. |
| | | Olivet College 20, Alma College 13 |
| Olivet | 1-G | at Olivet35 | Change of possession, ALMA ball on OLIVET25, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet25 | Jarrett Leister rush for loss of 4 yards to the OLIVET29 (Nate Roberts). |
| Alma | 2-14 | at Olivet29 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Ricky Roth. |
| Alma | 3-14 | at Olivet29 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Grant Wilson for 8 yards to the OLIVET21 (Noah Keefer;Beau Langs). |
| Alma | 4-6 | at Olivet21 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Grant Wilson, dropped pass. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Olivet College 20, Alma College 13 |