| | | Blake Iobe kickoff 48 yards to the ALMA22, Jon Bricker return 5 yards to the ALMA27 (Brett Wesner;Stefan McCoy). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma27 | Jarrett Leister rush for 3 yards to the ALMA30 (Travis Farris). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Alma30 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Barak Henderson. |
| Alma | 3-7 | at Alma30 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Ricky Roth for 6 yards to the ALMA36 (Aaron Breneman;Jake Messner). |
| Alma | 4-1 | at Alma36 | A. Montgomery punt 45 yards to the OLIVET19, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet19 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 13:23. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet19 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Edric Miller for 5 yards to the OLIVET24 (Brian Halas). |
| Olivet | 2-5 | at Olivet24 | Edric Miller rush for loss of 4 yards to the OLIVET20 (Garrett Thelen;Tony Galarno). |
| Olivet | 3-9 | at Olivet20 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams. |
| Olivet | 4-9 | at Olivet20 | Anthony Edwards punt 37 yards to the ALMA43, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:23 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma43 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 12:00. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma43 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 3 yards to the ALMA46 (Travis Farris;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Alma46 | PENALTY OLIVET Encroachment (Charlie Adams) 3 yards to the ALMA49. |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Alma49 | Jarrett Leister rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET46, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Jake Messner;Aaron Breneman). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet46 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Barak Henderson for 7 yards to the OLIVET39 (Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 2-3 | at Olivet39 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Ricky Roth. |
| Alma | 3-3 | at Olivet39 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Ricky Roth for 2 yards to the OLIVET37 (Aaron Breneman). |
| Alma | 4-1 | at Olivet37 | Jarrett Leister punt 22 yards to the OLIVET15, downed, PENALTY OLIVET personal foul (De'Marko Reed) 8 yards to the OLIVET7, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, 1st and 10, OLIVET ball on OLIVET7. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 20 yards, TOP 03:10 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet07 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 08:50. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet07 | Mike Martin rush for no gain to the OLIVET7 (A. Sabatella;Colin Kopke). |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet07 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Jon Beach, PENALTY ALMA pass interference (Luke Kanine) 14 yards to the OLIVET21, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet21 | Mike Martin rush for no gain to the OLIVET21 (Brian Halas), PENALTY OLIVET holding (Justin Schafer) 10 yards to the OLIVET11, NO PLAY. |
| Olivet | 1-20 | at Olivet11 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams. |
| Olivet | 2-20 | at Olivet11 | Mike Martin rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET18 (Ed Raby Jr.). |
| Olivet | 3-13 | at Olivet18 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams (Scotty Cole). |
| Olivet | 4-13 | at Olivet18 | Anthony Edwards punt 41 yards to the ALMA41, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 11 yards, TOP 01:46 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma41 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 07:04. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma41 | Jarrett Leister rush for 6 yards to the ALMA47 (Nick McCleary). |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Alma47 | Jarrett Leister rush for 2 yards to the ALMA49 (Ron Cadez;Ryan Armstrong). |
| Alma | 3-2 | at Alma49 | Jarrett Leister rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET48, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Ryan Armstrong;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet48 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Ricky Roth for 13 yards to the OLIVET35, 1ST DOWN ALMA, out-of-bounds (De'Marko Reed). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet35 | Matt Ruhlman rush for loss of 1 yard to the OLIVET36 (Ron Cadez;Jake Messner). |
| Alma | 2-11 | at Olivet36 | Jarrett Leister rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET34 (Travis Farris;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 3-9 | at Olivet34 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Matt Ruhlman (Ron Cadez). |
| Alma | 4-9 | at Olivet34 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Barak Henderson for 11 yards to the OLIVET23, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Rob Jensen;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet23 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Barak Henderson for 23 yards to the OLIVET0, clock 02:44, PENALTY ALMA pass interference (Barak Henderson) 15 yards to the OLIVET38, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 1-25 | at Olivet38 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Barak Henderson (Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 2-25 | at Olivet38 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Tyler Watters, QB hurry by Travis Farris. |
| Alma | 3-25 | at Olivet38 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to A. Montgomery for 38 yards to the OLIVET0, 1ST DOWN ALMA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:22. |
| | | Michael Reeves kick attempt failed. |
| | | Alma College 6, Olivet College 0 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 59 yards, TOP 04:42 |
| | | Michael Reeves kickoff 56 yards to the OLIVET14, Mike Martin return 17 yards to the OLIVET31, out-of-bounds (Andrew Funsch;A. Sabatella). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet31 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 02:18. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet31 | Edric Miller rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET38 (Garrett Thelen;Scotty Cole). |
| Olivet | 2-3 | at Olivet38 | Edric Miller rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET42, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (A. Sabatella;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet42 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Austin Khoshneg for 9 yards to the ALMA49 (Andrew Funsch;Brian Halas), PENALTY ALMA roughing passer (Brett Mageli) 15 yards to the ALMA34, 1ST DOWN OLIVET. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma34 | 1st and 10. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma34 | Edric Miller rush for 1 yard to the ALMA33 (A. Sabatella;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Alma33 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams, QB hurry by Garrett Thelen. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 36 yards, TOP 03:35 |
| | | Alma College 6, Olivet College 0 |
| Olivet | 3-9 | at Alma33 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Olivet | 3-9 | at Alma33 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to James Williams for 10 yards to the ALMA23, 1ST DOWN OLIVET. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma23 | Timeout Alma College, clock 14:40. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma23 | Edric Miller rush for 3 yards to the ALMA20 (A. Sabatella). |
| Olivet | 2-7 | at Alma20 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Jon Beach. |
| Olivet | 3-7 | at Alma20 | Daniel Bolster pass intercepted by Brian Halas at the ALMA5, Brian Halas return 71 yards to the OLIVET24 (Keegan Clark;Edric Miller). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 49 yards, TOP 03:35 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet24 | QB hurry by Johnathan Spenc. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet24 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 13:43. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet24 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Mike Lenneman (Aaron Breneman). |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Olivet24 | Jarrett Leister rush for no gain to the OLIVET24 (Travis Farris;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 3-10 | at Olivet24 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Matt Ruhlman, QB hurry by De'Marko Reed. |
| Alma | 4-10 | at Olivet24 | Michael Reeves field goal attempt from 41 MISSED - hit right upright, spot at OLIVET24, clock 12:50. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:53 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet24 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 12:50. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet24 | Mike Martin rush for 8 yards to the OLIVET32 (Scotty Cole;A. Sabatella). |
| Olivet | 2-2 | at Olivet32 | Mike Martin rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET39, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (A. Sabatella;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet39 | Mike Martin rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET40 (A. Sabatella;Ben Ward). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Olivet40 | Daniel Bolster sacked for loss of 2 yards to the OLIVET38 (Ben Ward;Frank Furnari), QB hurry by Tony Galarno. |
| Olivet | 3-11 | at Olivet38 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Jon Beach (Scotty Cole), QB hurry by Ed Raby Jr.. |
| Olivet | 4-11 | at Olivet38 | Fumble by recovered by OLIVET Anthony Edwards at OLIVET2, PENALTY OLIVET illegal kicking (Anthony Edwards) 1 yards to the OLIVET1. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, minus 23 yards, TOP 02:30 |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet01 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 10:20, 1st and 1. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet01 | Ed Mason rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:10. |
| | | Michael Reeves kick attempt failed. |
| | | Alma College 12, Olivet College 0 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| | | Michael Reeves kickoff 66 yards to the OLIVET4, James Williams return 18 yards to the OLIVET22 (Xavier Carranza;Steven Prine). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet22 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 10:05. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet22 | Edric Miller rush for loss of 1 yard to the OLIVET21 (A. Sabatella;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 2-11 | at Olivet21 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Austin Khoshneg (Scotty Cole). |
| Olivet | 3-11 | at Olivet21 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to James Williams for 4 yards to the OLIVET25 (A. Sabatella;Tony Galarno). |
| Olivet | 4-7 | at Olivet25 | Anthony Edwards punt 27 yards to the ALMA48, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:15 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma48 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 08:50. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma48 | Jarrett Leister pass intercepted by Rob Jensen at the OLIVET6, Rob Jensen return 0 yards to the OLIVET6. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:08 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet06 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 08:42. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet06 | Mike Martin rush for 8 yards to the OLIVET14 (Andrew Funsch), PENALTY ALMA personal foul off-setting, PENALTY OLIVET personal foul off-setting. |
| Olivet | 2-2 | at Olivet14 | Mike Martin rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET21, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Tony Galarno;Scotty Cole). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet21 | John Visel rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET28 (Scotty Cole;Brian Halas). |
| Olivet | 2-3 | at Olivet28 | Mike Martin rush for 11 yards to the OLIVET39, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Andrew Funsch;Brian Halas). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet39 | John Visel rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET40 (A. Sabatella;Ed Raby Jr.). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Olivet40 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams (Luke Kanine). |
| Olivet | 3-9 | at Olivet40 | Daniel Bolster rush for no gain to the OLIVET40 (A. Sabatella). |
| Olivet | 4-9 | at Olivet40 | Fumble by recovered by OLIVET Anthony Edwards at OLIVET28, PENALTY OLIVET illegal kicking (Anthony Edwards) 0 yards to the OLIVET28. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 22 yards, TOP 02:49 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 05:53, 1st and 10. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet28 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET21 (Travis Farris;Cody Boughton). |
| Alma | 2-3 | at Olivet21 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Mike Lenneman for 9 yards to the OLIVET12, 1ST DOWN ALMA, out-of-bounds (A.J. Moore). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet12 | Jarrett Leister rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET10 (De'Marko Reed). |
| Alma | 2-8 | at Olivet10 | Timeout Alma College, clock 04:00. |
| Alma | 2-8 | at Olivet10 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 10 yards to the OLIVET0, 1ST DOWN ALMA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:55. |
| | | Jarrett Leister pass attempt failed, QB hurry by De'Marko Reed. |
| | | Alma College 18, Olivet College 0 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 28 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| | | Michael Reeves kickoff 63 yards to the OLIVET7, James Williams return 15 yards to the OLIVET22 (Clayton Every;A. Sabatella). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet22 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 03:49. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet22 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Edric Miller for 1 yard to the OLIVET23 (Brian Halas). |
| Olivet | 2-9 | at Olivet23 | Edric Miller rush for no gain to the OLIVET23 (Frank Furnari;Brett Mageli). |
| Olivet | 3-9 | at Olivet23 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Jon Beach for 9 yards to the OLIVET32, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds, QB hurry by Tony Galarno. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet32 | Edric Miller rush for 12 yards to the OLIVET44, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Scotty Cole;Tony Galarno). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet44 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams, QB hurry by Brett Mageli. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet44 | Daniel Bolster sacked for loss of 9 yards to the OLIVET35 (Ed Raby Jr.;Tony Galarno). |
| Olivet | 3-19 | at Olivet35 | Daniel Bolster pass intercepted by Scotty Cole at the ALMA42, Scotty Cole return 24 yards to the OLIVET34 (Edric Miller), QB hurry by Frank Furnari. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 13 yards, TOP 02:59 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet34 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 00:50. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet34 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Barak Henderson (Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Olivet34 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Mike Lenneman for 17 yards to the OLIVET17, 1ST DOWN ALMA (A.J. Moore;Jake Messner), QB hurry by Ron Cadez. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet17 | Jarrett Leister rush for no gain to the OLIVET17, out-of-bounds (Cody Boughton), PENALTY ALMA holding (Matt Scharlow) 10 yards to the OLIVET27, NO PLAY. |
| Alma | 1-20 | at Olivet27 | Jarrett Leister sacked for loss of 13 yards to the OLIVET40 (Jake Messner). |
| Alma | 2-33 | at Olivet40 | Timeout Alma College, clock 00:10. |
| Alma | 2-33 | at Olivet40 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Mike Lenneman, QB hurry by Ryan Reurink. |
| Alma | 3-33 | at Olivet40 | PENALTY ALMA delay of game (Jarrett Leister) 5 yards to the OLIVET45. |
| Alma | 3-38 | at Olivet45 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Barak Henderson. |
| Alma | 4-38 | at Olivet45 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, minus 11 yards, TOP 00:50 |
| | | Alma College 18, Olivet College 0 |
| Alma | 4-38 | at Olivet45 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, ALMA ball on ALMA30. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, minus 11 yards, TOP 00:50 |
| | | Michael Reeves kickoff 70 yards to the OLIVET0, touchback. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 15:00. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | Mike Martin rush for 18 yards to the OLIVET38, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds (Brian Halas). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet38 | Mike Martin rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET42 (Scotty Cole;Tony Galarno). |
| Olivet | 2-6 | at Olivet42 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Jon Beach for 4 yards to the OLIVET46 (Andrew Funsch). |
| Olivet | 3-2 | at Olivet46 | Mike Martin rush for 1 yard to the OLIVET47 (Brian Halas;A. Sabatella). |
| Olivet | 4-1 | at Olivet47 | Mike Martin rush for loss of 2 yards to the OLIVET45 (Ed Raby Jr.;A. Sabatella). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 25 yards, TOP 02:08 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet45 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 12:52. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet45 | Jarrett Leister rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET41 (Ryan Reurink;Nick McCleary). |
| Alma | 2-6 | at Olivet41 | PENALTY ALMA false start (Matt Scharlow) 5 yards to the OLIVET46. |
| Alma | 2-11 | at Olivet46 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to A. Montgomery. |
| Alma | 3-11 | at Olivet46 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Ricky Roth. |
| Alma | 4-11 | at Olivet46 | A. Montgomery punt 20 yards to the OLIVET26, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:11 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet26 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 11:41. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet26 | Edric Miller rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET28 (Frank Furnari;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | at Olivet28 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to James Williams for 14 yards to the OLIVET42, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet42 | Edric Miller rush for 23 yards to the ALMA35, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Brian Halas). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma35 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 10:03. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma35 | Edric Miller rush for 2 yards to the ALMA33 (Ed Raby Jr.;Frank Furnari). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | at Alma33 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Jon Beach. |
| Olivet | 3-8 | at Alma33 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams. |
| Olivet | 4-8 | at Alma33 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Keegan Clark (Andrew Funsch), QB hurry by Ed Raby Jr.. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 41 yards, TOP 02:30 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma33 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 09:11. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma33 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 6 yards to the ALMA39 (Ryan Reurink;Nick McCleary). |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Alma39 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 3 yards to the ALMA42 (Travis Farris;Cody Boughton). |
| Alma | 3-1 | at Alma42 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 9 yards to the OLIVET49, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Nick McCleary). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet49 | Robert Feeman rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET45 (Nick McCleary;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 2-6 | at Olivet45 | Robert Feeman rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET41 (Cody Boughton;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 3-2 | at Olivet41 | Matt Ruhlman rush for loss of 3 yards to the OLIVET44 (Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 4-5 | at Olivet44 | PENALTY ALMA delay of game (A. Montgomery) 5 yards to the OLIVET49. |
| Alma | 4-10 | at Olivet49 | A. Montgomery punt 49 yards to the OLIVET0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 18 yards, TOP 03:46 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 05:25. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet20 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Jon Beach for 4 yards to the OLIVET24 (Andrew Funsch). |
| Olivet | 2-6 | at Olivet24 | Mike Martin rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET29 (Austin Smith). |
| Olivet | 3-1 | at Olivet29 | Daniel Bolster rush for loss of 1 yard to the OLIVET28, fumble by Daniel Bolster recovered by OLIVET Daniel Bolster at OLIVET28. |
| Olivet | 4-2 | at Olivet28 | Mike Martin rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET31, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (A. Sabatella;Ed Raby Jr.). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet31 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Jon Beach for 26 yards to the ALMA43, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Luke Kanine). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma43 | Mike Martin rush for 2 yards to the ALMA41 (Austin Smith;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 2-8 | at Alma41 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to James Williams, QB hurry by Conrad Bovee, PENALTY OLIVET illegal formation declined. |
| Olivet | 3-8 | at Alma41 | Daniel Bolster sacked for loss of 4 yards to the ALMA45 (Ed Raby Jr.). |
| Olivet | 4-12 | at Alma45 | Anthony Edwards punt 20 yards to the ALMA25, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 35 yards, TOP 04:19 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma25 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 01:06. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma25 | Jarrett Leister at QB for Alma College. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma25 | Jarrett Leister rush for no gain to the ALMA25 (Ryan Armstrong;Travis Farris). |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Alma25 | Jarrett Leister pass complete to Mike Lenneman for 7 yards to the ALMA32. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 7 yards, TOP 03:33 |
| | | Alma College 18, Olivet College 0 |
| Alma | 3-3 | at Alma32 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Alma | 3-3 | at Alma32 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 14 yards to the ALMA46, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Aaron Breneman;Jake Messner). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma46 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 3 yards to the ALMA49 (Ron Cadez;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 2-7 | at Alma49 | Jarrett Leister rush for 10 yards to the OLIVET41, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Jake Messner;De'Marko Reed). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet41 | Jarrett Leister rush for no gain to the OLIVET41 (Ryan Armstrong;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 2-10 | at Olivet41 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Barak Henderson (De'Marko Reed). |
| Alma | 3-10 | at Olivet41 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Aaron Hahn (Jake Messner). |
| Alma | 4-10 | at Olivet41 | A. Montgomery rush for 5 yards to the OLIVET36, out-of-bounds (Cody Boughton). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 39 yards, TOP 03:33 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet36 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 12:33. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet36 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to James Williams for 9 yards to the OLIVET45, out-of-bounds. |
| Olivet | 2-1 | at Olivet45 | Edric Miller rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET49, 1ST DOWN OLIVET (Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet49 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Keegan Clark, QB hurry by Brett Mageli. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet49 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Edric Miller (James McCoy). |
| Olivet | 3-10 | at Olivet49 | Daniel Bolster pass incomplete to Jon Beach, QB hurry by James McCoy. |
| Olivet | 4-10 | at Olivet49 | Anthony Edwards punt 43 yards to the ALMA8, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 13 yards, TOP 00:46 |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma08 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 11:47. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma08 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 6 yards to the ALMA14 (Ryan Reurink;Ryan Armstrong). |
| Alma | 2-4 | at Alma14 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Tyler Watters (Cody Boughton). |
| Alma | 3-4 | at Alma14 | Jarrett Leister rush for 6 yards to the ALMA20, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Nick McCleary;Jake Messner). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Alma20 | Matt Ruhlman rush for loss of 3 yards to the ALMA17 (Travis Farris). |
| Alma | 2-13 | at Alma17 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 1 yard to the ALMA18 (Cody Boughton;Travis Farris). |
| Alma | 3-12 | at Alma18 | Jarrett Leister pass incomplete to Ricky Roth, QB hurry by Jake Messner. |
| Alma | 4-12 | at Alma18 | A. Montgomery punt 36 yards to the OLIVET46, fair catch by James Williams. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 10 yards, TOP 02:55 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet46 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 08:52. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet46 | Mike Martin pass incomplete to James Williams. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet46 | Timeout Olivet College, clock 08:46. |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Olivet46 | Daniel Bolster sacked for loss of 7 yards to the OLIVET39 (Tony Galarno). |
| Olivet | 3-17 | at Olivet39 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Mike Martin for 9 yards to the OLIVET48 (A. Sabatella;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 4-8 | at Olivet48 | Fumble by Alec Slobin, fumble by recovered by OLIVET Anthony Edwards at OLIVET10, clock 07:18, Change of possession, ALMA ball on OLIVET10, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 36 yards, TOP 01:34 |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet10 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 07:18. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet10 | Matt Ruhlman rush for no gain to the OLIVET10, fumble by Matt Ruhlman recovered by OLIVET Nick McCleary at OLIVET10. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet10 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 07:08. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet10 | Edric Miller rush for no gain to the OLIVET10, fumble by Edric Miller recovered by ALMA James Marker at OLIVET10, PENALTY OLIVET personal foul (Travis Farris) 5 yards to the OLIVET5, 1st and 10, ALMA ball on OLIVET5, PENALTY OLIVET unsportsmanli
ke conduct (Austin Khoshneg) 2 yards to the OLIVET3, 1st and 10, ALMA ball on OLIVET3. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet03 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 07:01. |
| | | 82 on Olivet was ejected from the game. |
| Alma | 1-G | at Olivet03 | Matt Ruhlman rush for no gain to the OLIVET3 (Ron Cadez;Ryan Reurink). |
| Alma | 2-G | at Olivet03 | Aaron Hahn rush for 3 yards to the OLIVET0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:30. |
| | | Michael Reeves kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Ryan Armstrong). |
| | | Alma College 24, Olivet College 0 |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:31 |
| | | Michael Reeves kickoff 63 yards to the OLIVET7, Mike Martin return 26 yards to the OLIVET33, out-of-bounds. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet33 | OLIVET COLLEGE drive start at 06:15. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Olivet33 | Mike Martin rush for 6 yards to the OLIVET39 (Garrett Thelen;Conrad Bovee). |
| Olivet | 2-4 | at Olivet39 | Daniel Bolster rush for no gain to the OLIVET39 (Ryan Nelson;Ben Ward). |
| Olivet | 3-4 | at Olivet39 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Joseph Camble for 12 yards to the ALMA49, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, out-of-bounds. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma49 | Mike Martin rush for 3 yards to the ALMA46. |
| Olivet | 2-7 | at Alma46 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Jon Beach for 30 yards to the ALMA16, 1ST DOWN OLIVET. |
| Olivet | 1-10 | at Alma16 | Mike Martin rush for no gain to the ALMA16 (Garrett Thelen). |
| Olivet | 2-10 | at Alma16 | Daniel Bolster pass complete to Jon Beach for 16 yards to the ALMA0, 1ST DOWN OLIVET, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:15. |
| | | Blake Iobe kick attempt good. |
| | | Alma College 24, Olivet College 7 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 67 yards, TOP 03:00 |
| | | Blake Iobe kickoff 50 yards to the ALMA20, Luke Kanine return 35 yards to the OLIVET45, out-of-bounds. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet45 | ALMA COLLEGE drive start at 03:04. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet45 | Robert Feeman at QB for Alma College. |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet45 | Aaron Hahn rush for 7 yards to the OLIVET38 (De'Marko Reed;Rob Jensen). |
| Alma | 2-3 | at Olivet38 | Matt Ruhlman rush for loss of 1 yard to the OLIVET39 (Cody Boughton;Jake Messner). |
| Alma | 3-4 | at Olivet39 | Robert Feeman rush for 2 yards to the OLIVET37 (Cody Boughton;Ron Cadez). |
| Alma | 4-2 | at Olivet37 | Matt Ruhlman rush for 4 yards to the OLIVET33, 1ST DOWN ALMA (Ryan Reurink;Nick McCleary). |
| Alma | 1-10 | at Olivet33 | Robert Feeman rush for loss of 2 yards to the OLIVET35. |
| Alma | 2-12 | at Olivet35 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Olivet win toss. Elects to defer |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 10 yards, TOP 03:04 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Alma College 24, Olivet College 7 |