Theresa (Damico) Underhill

Bio

You earned four varsity letters on the women’s golf team, leading Olivet to three MIAA championships and three appearances at the NCAA Division III Championships.

You were a four-time All-MIAA selection -- First Team honoree in 2011, 2012 and 2013, and Second Team honoree in 2010. In 2012, you earned MIAA Most Valuable Golfer honors after averaging 78.2 strokes over six rounds. In addition, you were named a WGCA All-American in 2013 and WGCA All-Region selection in 2013 and 2014.

At the time of your graduation, you held the women’s golf career scoring average record (81.8 strokes over 96 rounds). The mark still ranks second in Olivet history. In school history, you are tied for the third-best 18-hole score (72) and tied for the fourth-best 36-hole score (150). The 72 and 150 are also the best scores in program history at Olivet’s home course, The Medalist Golf Club.

After graduating from Olivet with a bachelor’s degree in biology, you began your working career in automotive industry. You currently work as a sales manager at Mann+Hummel in Portage. You are married to Ryan Underhill, a 2012 Olivet graduate. Together, you have two wonderful children, Amelia and Henri.

Olivet honors you and is proud to induct you into The University of Olivet Athletic Hall of Fame on this 26th day of September, 2025.